Antarctic neutrino detector firms up cosmic neutrino sighting

Thursday, August 20, 2015 - 10:00am

Sorting through the billions of subatomic particles that zip through its frozen cubic-kilometer-sized detector each year, researchers using the IceCube Neutrino Observatory have gathered powerful new evidence in support of 2013 observations confirming the existence of cosmic neutrinos.

The new observations are important because they herald a new form of astronomy using neutrinos, nearly massless high energy particles generated in nature’s accelerators: black holes, massive exploding stars and the energetic cores of galaxies. In the new study, the detection of 21 ultra high-energy muons – secondary particles created on the very rare occasions when neutrinos interact with other particles – from the mass of particles coursing upward through the IceCube detector provides independent confirmation of astrophysical neutrinos from our galaxy as well as cosmic neutrinos from sources outside the Milky Way.

high energy event
This is the one of the 21 highest-energy neutrinos of this study. It was detected by the IceCube Neutrino Observatory at the South Pole on October 28, 2010. A muon neutrino interacting with the ice in or around IceCube will create a muon, which leaves a track of light while crossing the detector. Neutrino-induced muons do not deposit all their energy in IceCube. But, scientists are able to estimate the most probable energy both for the detected muon and the initial neutrino. For this event, the most probable muon energy is 604 TeV, and the most probably neutrino energy is 880 TeV. Image: IceCube Collaboration

 

The new observations were reported today in a paper published in the journal Physical Review Letters by the IceCube Collaboration, which called the new observation an “unequivocal signal” for astrophysical neutrinos, ultra high-energy particles that have traversed space unimpeded by stars, planets, galaxies, magnetic fields or clouds of interstellar dust, phenomena that, at very high energies, significantly attenuate more mundane particles like photons.

Because they have almost no mass and no electric charge, neutrinos can be very hard to detect and are only observed indirectly when they collide with other particles to create muons, telltale secondary particles. What’s more, there are different kinds of neutrinos produced in different astrophysical processes and sifting through a mass of observations to identify perhaps a few dozen of the highest energy neutrinos that have travelled from sources in the Milky Way and beyond our galaxy is a huge challenge for the IceCube Collaboration, a large international consortium headquartered at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

Those high-energy neutrinos, scientists believe, are created deep inside some of the universe’s most violent phenomena. The particles created in these events, including neutrinos and cosmic rays, are accelerated to energy levels that exceed the record setting Earthbound accelerators such as the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) by more than a million. They are prized by astrophysicists because the information they hold is pristine, unchanged as the particles travel millions of light years between their sources and Earth. The ability to study the highest energy neutrinos promises insight into a host of problems in physics, including how nature builds powerful and efficient particle accelerators in the universe.

The latest observations were made by pointing the Ice Cube Observatory – composed of thousands of optical sensors sunk deep beneath the Antarctic ice at the South Pole – through the Earth to observe the Northern Hemisphere sky. The Earth serves as a filter to help weed out a confusing background of muons created when cosmic rays crash into the Earth’s atmosphere.

“Looking for muon neutrinos reaching the detector through the Earth is the way IceCube was supposed to do neutrino astronomy and it has delivered,” explains Francis Halzen, a UW-Madison professor of physics and the principal investigator of IceCube. “This is as close to independent confirmation as one can get with a unique instrument.”

Between May 2010 and May 2012, IceCube recorded more than 35,000 neutrinos. However, only about 20 of those neutrino events were clocked at energy levels indicative of astrophysical or cosmic sources.

sky map
Sky map in equatorial coordinates of the arrival direction of the 21 highest-energy events of this analysis (red dotted circles). The most probable neutrino energy (in TeV) indicated for each event assumes the best-fit astrophysical flux of the analysis. For comparison, the events of the 3-year high-energy starting event (HESE) analysis with deposited energy larger than 60 TeV (tracks and cascades) are also shown. Cascade events are indicated together with their median angular uncertainty (thin circles). Image: IceCube Collaboration

 

The results are meaningful because, using the different technique, they reaffirm the IceCube Observatory’s ability to sample the ghostlike neutrinos. By instrumenting a cubic kilometer of deep Antarctic ice, scientists were able to make a detector big enough to capture the signature of the rare neutrino collision. When that rare smashup occurs, it creates a muon, which, in turn, leaves a trail of Cherenkov light that faithfully mirrors the trajectory of the neutrino. The “optical sonic booms” created when neutrinos smash into another particle are sensed by the optical sensors that make up the IceCube detector array and, in theory, can be used to point back to a source.

"This is an excellent confirmation of IceCube’s recent discoveries, opening the doors to a new era in particle physics," says Vladimir Papitashvili, astrophysics & geospace sciences program director in the National Science Foundation’s (NSF) Division of Polar Programs. "And it became possible only because of extraordinary qualities of Antarctic ice and NSF's ability to successfully tackle enormous scientific and logistical problems in the most inhospitable places on Earth."

But while the new observations confirm the existence of astrophysical neutrinos and the means to detect them using the IceCube Observatory, actual point sources of high-energy neutrinos remain to be identified.

Albrecht Karle, a UW-Madison professor of physics and a senior author of the Physical Review Letters report, notes that while the neutrino-induced tracks recorded by the IceCube detector have a good pointing resolution, within less than a degree, the IceCube team has not observed a significant number of neutrinos emanating from any single source.

The neutrinos observed in the latest search, however, have energy levels identical to those seen when the observatory sampled the sky of the southern hemisphere. That, says Karle, suggests that many of the potential sources of the highest energy neutrinos are generated beyond the Milky Way. If there were a significant number of sources in our own galaxy, he notes, the IceCube detector would light up when observing the plane of our galaxy, the region where most neutrino-generating sources would likely be found.

“The plane of the galaxy is where the stars are. It is where cosmic rays are accelerated, so you would expect to see more sources there. But the highest energy neutrinos we’ve observed come from random directions,” says Karle, whose former graduate student, Chris Weaver, is the corresponding author of the new study. “It is sound confirmation that the discovery of cosmic neutrinos from beyond our galaxy is real.”

IceCube is operated by an international consortium and is based at the Wisconsin IceCube Particle Astrophysics Center (WIPAC) at UW-Madison. The observatory was built with major support from the National Science Foundation as well as support from partner funding agencies worldwide. More than 300 physicists and engineers from the United States, Germany, Sweden, Belgium, Switzerland, Japan, Canada, New Zealand, Australia, the United Kingdom, Korea and Denmark are involved in the project.

+ info "Evidence for Astrophysical Muon Neutrinos from the Northern Sky with IceCube," IceCube Collaboration: M.G. Aartsen et al. Physical Review Letters 115, 081102 (2015).

Contacts:

Francis Halzen, PI IceCube
Hilldale and Gregory Breit Distinguished Professor of Physics
University of Wisconsin–Madison

francis.halzen@icecube.wisc.edu

Albrecht Karle, IceCube Associate Director, Science and Instrumentation
Professor of Physics
University of Wisconsin–Madison
 albrecht.karle@icecube.wisc.edu

Note: A multimedia gallery is available at: icecube.wisc.edu/gallery

The IceCube Collaboration has also released data related to this paper.

Read here about the first evidence for astrophysical neutrinos (Science, November 2013)