First search for ultra-high-energy neutrinos with the Askaryan Radio Array

A construction site for ARA. Credit: Justin Gilbert, NSF/ARA

The origin of ultra-high-energy (UHE) cosmic rays, with energies far higher than what can be produced by man-made accelerators on Earth, remains one of the biggest mysteries in astrophysics. UHE neutrinos that are created by these particles can help to trace their origins and uncover the cosmic accelerators that power them.

The Askaryan Radio Array (ARA), located at the South Pole near the Nobel Prize–winning IceCube Neutrino Observatory, searches for the highest energy neutrinos by observing the radio pulses they generate as they travel through the Antarctic ice. The radio pulses come from the so-called “Askaryan Effect” in which a shower of particles in a dense material emits coherent radio waves. These radio pulses are picked up by ARA’s five “stations,” each of which is made up of a cluster of in-ice radio antennas. 

Recently, the KM3NeT Collaboration announced the observation of the first UHE neutrino, demonstrating that these particles exist and that more sensitive detectors, including in-ice Askaryan detector arrays, are needed to precisely measure their flux.

For the first time, a search for UHE neutrinos was performed by treating ARA as a single observatory. Using over a decade of data, the ARA Collaboration has set the tightest constraints on how common neutrinos are at the highest energies, helping astrophysicists rule out some explanations for the origins of cosmic rays that are otherwise consistent with existing data. The results are presented in a joint submission to Physical Review Letters and Physical Review D. 

The 90% CL upper limit on the all-flavor diffuse UHE neutrino flux set by this analysis (thick red line). Previous constraints and measurements from IceCube, KM3NeT, Auger, ANITA, ARIANNA, and earlier ARA analyses are also shown (colored lines). The optimization was performed on a flux model corresponding to the global upper limit (boundary of grey region). All upper limits are converted to equivalent all-flavor limits using decade-wide bins. Adjustments are not made for differences in the assumed spectral index within each bin. Illustrative UHE neutrino flux models are presented (grey dashed lines). Credit: ARA Collaboration
The 90% CL upper limit on the all-flavor diffuse UHE neutrino flux set by this analysis (thick red line). Previous constraints and measurements from IceCube, KM3NeT, Auger, ANITA, ARIANNA, and earlier ARA analyses are also shown (colored lines). The optimization was performed on a flux model corresponding to the global upper limit (boundary of grey region). All upper limits are converted to equivalent all-flavor limits using decade-wide bins. Adjustments are not made for differences in the assumed spectral index within each bin. Illustrative UHE neutrino flux models are presented (grey dashed lines). Credit: ARA Collaboration
A headshot of a man with dark hair.
Marco Muzio

Led by researchers at the Wisconsin IceCube Particle Astrophysics Center (WIPAC) of the University of Wisconsin–Madison, the work was carried out by an eight-person team across six institutions from the ARA Collaboration. WIPAC played a key role in the study, including in data analysis and detector maintenance. WIPAC postdoctoral researcher Marco Muzio led the team that analyzed the data from ARA’s full five-station array while recent PhD graduate Abby Bishop was the lead analyzer of data from ARA’s second station. 

“This work was unusual in that it was a truly collaborative effort carried out by students and postdocs from different institutions working in close coordination, almost exclusively remotely,” says Muzio. “I’m really proud of what this team has accomplished and I’m excited to see how others build on this work, improve it, and go on to discover the highest energy neutrinos ever observed.” 

Bishop and Muzio also fully upgraded the simulation software used to understand ARA’s sensitivity, and Bishop deployed to the South Pole in 2024 to maintain and upgrade the detector.

A woman in a red winter jacket working in a pit at the South Pole.
Abby Bishop working on station A4. Credit: Kayla DeHolton

“It feels very rewarding to finally submit this analysis, which was originally proposed over five years ago,” says Bishop. “A great deal of ingenuity, overtime, and teamwork went into every step of the process. I was very lucky to work with our team and learn so much about hardware, simulation, and analysis from ARA.”

The study represents a major milestone for in-ice Askaryan detector arrays, demonstrating their ability to suppress backgrounds even near man-made sources. Furthermore, this analysis provides a foundation for future searches using ARA and next-generation radio detectors, like the Radio Neutrino Observatory in Greenland (under construction) and the IceCube-Gen2 radio neutrino observatory, which will be located in the same environment as ARA.

A few people wearing winter jackets digging out a pit at the South Pole.
From left to right: Abby Bishop, John Kelley, and Sasha Novikov dig out station A4. The ARA drilling shed can be seen in the background. Credit: Kayla DeHolton

“Bringing together data from all five ARA stations into a single analysis marks a major milestone for the collaboration after many years of effort,” says Albrecht Karle, principal investigator of ARA and a professor of physics at UW–Madison. “Looking ahead, we are developing plans for a much larger radio observatory as part of IceCube-Gen2 that would monitor roughly 1,000 cubic kilometers of Antarctic ice in our quest to discover the origin of the highest-energy particles in the universe.”

+ info “New Constraints on the Ultrahigh Energy Neutrino Flux from the First Array-Wide Search with the Askaryan Radio Array,” ARA Collaboration: N. Alden et al., Submitted to Physical Review Letters, arXiv and “Analysis Methodology of the Search for Ultrahigh Energy Neutrinos in 10.6 Years of Askaryan Radio Array Data,” ARA Collaboration: N. Alden et al., Submitted to Physical Review D, arXiv